the Pavle Milić show
Pavle Milic has spent 40+ years in the hospitality business — co-founding FnB restaurant in Scottsdale, building Los Milics Vineyards across three Arizona tasting rooms, and writing about wine for Phoenix Magazine for the past decade. Now he's pulling up a chair with people from well outside his own world and seeing where the conversation goes.
If you have any questions or ideas for an upcoming show, and if you would like to be a guest on the show, email psst@pavlemilic.com
Cheers!
the Pavle Milić show
019: An Anthem to Life in a Glass with Chateau Musar's Marc Hochar
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Join me as I engage in an illuminating conversation with Marc Hochar at the iconic Chateau Musar in Lebanon. We unravel the rich tapestry of the Hochar family's legacy and their remarkable influence on the world of winemaking, tracing back through millennia to the Phoenician pioneers. Discover the pivotal moment when Gaston Hochar left a medical career in France to embrace the fertile Bekaa Valley and how his son Serge propelled their soulful wines onto the global stage. Despite Lebanon's complex history, Chateau Musar stands as a testament to resilience and quality, with its wines becoming vessels of memory and identity.
In this episode, you will hear:
- Exploration of Chateau Musar's rich winemaking legacy in Lebanon.
- Insights from Marc Hochar on the Hochar family's influence in global wine.
- Historical roots of Lebanese winemaking dating back to Phoenician times.
- Innovative viticulture techniques to combat climate challenges.
- Unique qualities and evolution of Chateau Musar's white wines.
- The enduring legacy and cultural significance of Lebanese cuisine and hospitality.
Resources from this Episode
Follow and Review:
We’d love for you to follow us if you haven’t yet. Click that purple '+' in the top right corner of your Apple Podcasts app. We’d love it even more if you could drop a review or 5-star rating over on Apple Podcasts. Simply select “Ratings and Reviews” and “Write a Review” then a quick line with your favorite part of the episode. It only takes a second and it helps spread the word about the podcast.
Episode Credits
If you like this podcast and are thinking of creating your own, consider talking to my producer, Emerald City Productions. They helped me grow and produce the podcast you are listening to right now. Find out more at https://emeraldcitypro.com Let them know we sent you.
Welcome to Wine World, the podcast that takes you from vineyard to glass. Each episode, your host Pompey Milich, winemaker, restauranteur, and columnist, explores wine grape growing, winemaking, and wine and food pairings, focusing on Arizona and beyond. Join us as we visit vineyards, chat with restaurateurs, and meet the pioneers behind top wineries. Whether you're a wine enthusiast or curious about starting your own winery, Wineworld offers the perfect blend of education and entertainment. Pour yourself a glass and tune in to discover the stories behind the bottle.
SPEAKER_02In this episode, I sit down with Marc Lochard of Chateau Moussar. Now, that name may ring familiar to those in the restaurant world, to Sommelier's, and to winemakers across the globe. Why? Because although it hails from what many might consider an unlikely place, Lebanon, a country shaped by war, occupation, resilience, and reinvention, Moussar has managed to carve out an indelible place in the global wine conversation. Lebanon, bordered by Israel to the south, Syria to the northeast, has seen more than its share of upheaval over the past century. And yet, this region has been producing wine for over 6,000 years. Its relationship with the vine is as ancient as civilization itself. The Mussar story begins in 1930, when Gaston Hoshar returned to Lebanon from France. He had left behind the life in medical school and with it a more conventional future. What he brought back instead was a deep, abiding love for wine, innovation. From that, he began making wine in the Becca Valley. What followed was a remarkable tale of family, legacy, and tenacity in a land where time itself often feels negotiable and the future never guaranteed. In this conversation, we trace the Hoshar family's journey, a path both tenuous and transcendent through decades of conflict, discovery, and persistence. It's also a story of Serge Hoshar, the Gaston's son, the philosopher, winemaker who, when Lebanon became too unstable to support wine cells at home, took Chateau Moussard to the world, and in doing so redefined what it means to make wine with salt. So how did I end up here? Sitting across from Mark Hoshar. Well, as it is often the case in this industry, things only make sense in hindsight. In 2015, I was invited by Ray Ile, executive wine editor of Food and Wine magazine, to the inaugural Somcon in Aspen. It ran parallel to the annual Food and Wine Classic, bringing together sommelier and buyers from across the country for three immersive days of seminars and tastings. Of all the experiences that weekend, one moment etched itself into my memory. A seminar led by Richard Betts of Astral Tequila and An Approach to Relaxation Wines. He featured a comparative tasting between Terry Layton's Caitlin Sellers and Chateau Musar. But it became something else entirely, less a tasting and more of a meditation. Before Mark began speaking, Richard's partner, Carla, asked to say a few words. Serge Hoshar had passed away the year prior. What followed was an impromptu eulogy delivered through tears, an expression of reverence for a man who was equal parts poet, philosopher, and generous soul. She spoke of Serge's rare ability to offer presents to truly see the person in front of him. Then we tasted the 1974 Chateau Mussar. Coming on the heels of Carla's emotional words, the wine's electric, unfiltered life hit like a wave. It wasn't trying to be anything, it simply was. I had never tasted anything like it. The room quieted, we were all, whether we realized it or not, in the moment. Since that day, Mussar has held a permanent place on the wine list at FMB. As a winemaker, these bottles represent something aspirational, though impossible to replicate. They remind us that wine is more than the product, its memory, its time, its identity. Believe that our experience with wine is shaped by who we are, by our bodies, our souls, the people we're with, the context of the moment. He taught us to take slowly, to reserve judgment, to see wine and people for that matter, through all of their incarnations. I hope you enjoyed this conversation as much as I did. Open something special and raise a glass to love, to presence, and to humanity. So I think it was, I want to say over ten years ago, I was invited to the first SomCom in Aspen, Colorado.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_02And it was a three-day Shindega. I was invited by Ray Isle. And it was amazing seminars. But the one that stood out the most, the MC for that seminar was Richard Betts.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02And on the table was two distinctive wines. I think the title of the seminar was something about age-worthy wines and how we no longer get to enjoy age-worthy wines. And we have Kaylin Sellers, made by a now his past former biochemist that was making Sauvignon Blanc that he would release like 35,000 years later. Correct. And then to the right of Richard Betts, it's you, and you're serving Chateau Moussard. So before we even start tasting, a few people get up. I think this was at the heels of your dad having passed. And Richard Betts partner, Carla, got up and gave sort of an impromptu, kind of like from the heart, sentiment about what your father meant to her with tears in her eyes. This is before we start tasting. And I'm sitting there going, What is going on? And who is this guy, Sergey? Or who was he? Anyways, we get to the tasting. And I'm gonna interrupt that part of the story because I was just interviewed. I write a column for Phoenix Magazine, and this is at my 10th year anniversary. And in some of the questions that were asked, one of them was, What were some wines or a wine that sort of captivated you? And I had two answers. One was a floor-stacked, cheap pepperwood grow Pinot Noir for $3.99, which was all I can afford and share with my father. That was one. Okay. And it was not really so much about the wine, it was about the memory with my father and when we used to cook together. The second one, Mark, was a 1974 Chateau Moussard. And what I said about this wine, besides the fact that it was not only arresting in its unique signature, it was brimming with life. But it was the type of wine that kind of suspended reality and forced you to be in the moment. And it was unusually refreshing, unusually flavorful. It had like gravitas, but at the same time, it was like stardust. You can't define it. Anyway, so after that seminar, I became a sycophant, a groupie of Chateau Moussard, and I put it at my restaurant. So when I heard that you were going to be in town, I was really excited to sit down with you and talk about Chateau Moussard. So I'm going to give you kind of like a little direction, maybe, and then we'll, wherever this takes, we'll go, we'll go there. I think it's really important that although in our line of work, people that are in the industry and people who are wine lovers, aficionados, they might know of Chateau Moussar. I still to this day get to introduce people to Chateau Moussar, and they're flummox by provenance when I tell them it's from Lebanon. Interestingly enough, they start trying to think, well, where is Lebanon? Yes. You know, but because the Middle East, you know, not everybody is an expert on the geography there.
SPEAKER_01By the way, I checked, I think there are 29 Lebanons in the US. Because I was checking this yesterday on uh AI search engine. 29 of them. But obviously the the Lebanon, Lebanon is yeah, in the Middle East, in the eastern Mediterranean side.
SPEAKER_02Okay. All right. So I think that at the just to get the conversation going, we should go a little 30,000 feet, meaning let's talk about the breadbasket of Lebanon, otherwise known as the Becca Valley, which by the way, I've seen two spellings, one with a K, one with a Q. We'll get to that. I think it's really important to maybe touch a little bit on your grandfather and how he decided I don't want medicine, I want winemaking. Correct. Then there's another important date that stands out in my mind, which is 1959, when your father, Sergei, gave him an ultimatum if he were to take on the reins. Then we have to fast forward to 1979 when Michael Broadband, or his son, or whomever, who knows, is still controversial. Okay, Michael discovered it. How he ostensibly kind of put you on the map. And then we can briefly talk maybe about 1984 Men of the Year wine enthusiast and the decanter. Decanter, sorry. And the I guess it was the truck fermentation. Was that the same year? 84 was actually the truck fermented vintage.
SPEAKER_01Correct, yes.
SPEAKER_02And then we'll just then talk about the the wines in general. So let's go back and talk about your grandfather.
SPEAKER_01Yes, yes. Actually, we could even start earlier than my grandfather, because you know, people don't think of Lebanon as a wine-producing country. But we've been producing wines in Lebanon for six to six and a half thousand years. You know, if you think of the Phoenicians, not the Venetians as in Venice, uh Italy, but Phoenicians, P-H-O-E-Nitians. So they used to live in what is now Lebanon. They were our ancestors. They used to produce wines, and what they also did was they traded them. They used to have boats traded across the whole of the Mediterranean. And this is how wine went from the Middle East gradually westward. So the history of winemaking started way earlier. And I guess the what I always mention is the first thing when people ask how come there's wine in Lebanon is I look at a glass of water and I say, There's a certain person 2,000 years ago who took that glass of water and turned it into wine. Yeah. And when Jesus had his first miracle at the wedding of Kana, it was Kana is in southern Lebanon, and so and he didn't turn water into tequila or gin or anything else, but wine, because it was part of the culture. Now eventually with Islam, wine production stopped in that part of the world. And then it started again in the 1850s with monks who produced. And then my grandfather decided in 1930 to start the winery. He actually tried to, I mean, wanted to study initially medicine in France, didn't really enjoy it, came back to Lebanon loving wine, and then started the winery Chateau Miser.
SPEAKER_02What was that like in 1930? I'm assuming he started from scratch. There was no existing vineyards. Well, or some?
SPEAKER_01Well, he started from scratch in terms of money. He had zero because after World War I and the demise of the Ottoman Empire, his family lost everything. And he so he asked farmers to plant. At the time, Philoxera had, as far as we know, decimated a lot of the varietals that were in Lebanon, except some whites, peculiar whites that go into our Chateau Miza White, two local white grapes, that were a bit more remote in remote villages, a bit even higher up altitude than the Becca Valley, where most of the plants, most of the vines were planted at that time. And so he had to plant new varietals or and at least new vines. And so he, because of his stint in France, it made sense to bring in varietals from France, in particular Rhone, because of the heat that we have in Lebanon and that they would be probably the most adapted for the terroir. And so he asked farmers to plant and then just bought the grapes and started making wines. And at the time the French were posted in Lebanon between World War I and World War II, and they wanted wine. So there's there's even some years where they came in and said, okay, we need wine. We were, I think, the second producer. And they said, okay, we'll take everything. So the good thing is that in all the wine. I mean the whole vintage of wines. At the time we were starting to sell in the local market, but you know, there there are some years where they just took everything, but not take as in take without paying. I mean, they were paying for it. It's not that they were not.
SPEAKER_02That's amazing.
SPEAKER_01But um so this is how basically it probably helped kick start the interest locally and also have the sales. And then it's only at the next generation when my father came in. My father and monk, my uncle joined late 50s, early 60s. And as you say, the story goes that my grandfather asked my father to join. He wasn't a winemaker. My father was just 20 years old at the time. And he asked him to join, my father said no. Asked a second time, still no, uh, same answer, third time from what I what my father said tells me. I didn't meet my grandfather that long, actually. I was very young when he passed away. And he said, okay, I'll I'll come, but you have to go. So um, and and go, I mean, eventually, yeah, he left. But the idea that was that my father wanted to have the full reins on how to make the wines. And and his approach was that if the Phoenicians used to produce wines, you know, thousands of years ago, without any treatment, without adding things to the wine, without all the technology that was introduced in the 50s and 60s into winemaking, then let's do the same. And so he stopped using yeasts. So we have a natural fermentation that happens at Mizar since the 60s. We don't filter the wines, the reds, we don't find them, we don't extract anything, we don't add anything. We have what we call is a non-interventionist approach to winemaking. And in the 60s, it was the opposite of the trend. Everybody was going towards more technology, towards more industrialization of wine, and we went the exact opposite way. Now the market has turned, and people are now going back to autochthonous grapes, to uh organic, natural winemaking, biodynamic, depends on how far you want to stretch it. And that's become the motto, the marketing aspect of a lot of wineries. But for us, you know, it's been a part of our DNA. And so we the market just came back to what we thought was the right way of doing things.
SPEAKER_02Mark, now that we're talking about before we get to the passing of the torch to the next generation, something about the Chateau Moussar story is actually the geography, not only of this valley, which is actually a higher valley, if if I did my research correctly, but even the trajectory from the vineyard to where the wine is made is very much part of the story. I do commute from Phoenix to my vineyard two and a half hours away, but but the winery is right on site, it's a state vineyard. You guys have a hell of a commute and has also been the platform for quite a lot of folklore in your story.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Yeah, we so when my grandfather started the winery, he used an old convent called the Msar Palace, owned by his cousin. And it's in that convent, in the cellars of that convent, that basically he he built the first vats and where the wine was being made. And the name Mussar comes from Msar, which is the name of that palace. And that was in the heart of the Christian areas, the Christian area of Lebanon, knowing that Lebanon at the time was less than 10 years old as a country. And it was a combination of putting together areas that were Christian, Shiite, Sunite, different areas. And so he wasn't sure that the country would survive. And so he wanted to make sure that at least the production was in the Christian areas, you know, knowing that we're Christians. But the vineyards had to be in the historical part of Lebanon in terms of wine growing, not wine growing, but just vegetables, agriculture in general. And that is the Bikar Valley. And the Bikar Valley is at uh 3,000 feet of altitude and stuck between two chains of mountains that go up to 10,000 feet. One chain of mountain is to the east of the Baikar Valley, protects us from the desert in Syria and the heat. And another chain of mountain is to the west of the Baikar Valley and actually is protecting us from the sea and from the humidity. So it's a microclimate very unique to the region. I don't think we're Mediterranean as a pure Mediterranean climate there. I think it's between Mediterranean and continental, in the sense that we get snow in the winter, you know, we get rain, but then as soon as we hit April or May, it stops raining until harvest, which happens in August and September. And so it's an ideal terroir.
SPEAKER_02Was the vineyard always dry farmed since its inception, as far as you know? I don't know. Okay. I'll be very honest, I don't know. Because you're you're an outlier. I mean, very few vineyards can actually do what you do.
SPEAKER_01I don't know in terms of farming at the time of my grandfather. I know that my when my father took over, we almost have and at the time we used to buy a lot of grapes. And gradually we started buying land, we started renting land, and so we we now farm 95% of the juice of the grapes that we that we use. And all of that is dry farming. And we've had organic vineyards since you know 20 years in terms of certification, but it was already almost organic before then, because we were not irrigating. And when you irrigate, you get more juice, but you get less concentration. Yeah. And in the end, what we have are very low yields on purpose. We're talking, I mean you're a technical person, so we don't understand 25 hectoliters per hectare, which is roughly 40 around 40% of a normal production. And that's because we're not concentrating on, I guess, the financial side. We're focusing on the wine side. And for us, it's more crucial to get this intense intense flavors that come with low yields rather than just you know producing a lot of juice and uh and making a lot of wine out of it. Old bushvines? And it's old bush vines, yeah. Yes. Because if you use trellises, you expose your grapes to much more heat and sun, and the canopy doesn't protect them well. So because we don't irrigate, the only way really to protect our are our few grapes that are, or a few clusters that are part of the vine, is to have bushvines with the canopy protecting them from the sun.
SPEAKER_02You don't do any training, you don't drop any leaves, nothing. You got or what kind of viticulture is involved in the management of the actual vine?
SPEAKER_01So obviously we have some pruning at one point that happens. You know, we do use tractors just to plow the land, just to basically air it so that there is a bit of air that comes in, and that really helps the vines in terms of uh looking for what they need in terms of nutrients. Otherwise, everything is done by hand. Obviously, we we we cut, it depends on which varietal, how many nodes you keep, and it's always work in progress and discovery. Not because we we don't know how to do it, but there's just always a new way of doing it, a new way of tweaking it. We're more and more exposed to heat, to heat waves since 2010. It's been almost uh dominant every year in terms of losing 20 to 30 percent of our production. So that's a lot. And so we're tweaking a little bit at the margin. And we're also using new varietals as we plant new varietals just to discover those that resist well to heat. We've done a plant in Tempranillo around 15 years ago. We now make a wine out of it as a blend, always as a blend. And yeah, so it's a it's a permanent discovery as we go along, even after 95 years.
SPEAKER_02Which is yes, five years away from from a hundred. It's amazing. That's a good segue. Let's let's briefly touch on your grandfather, was the one that initially selected Cavernet Sauvignon, Senseau, and Carignan. Was that always the trifecta, the triumvirate? It wasn't.
SPEAKER_01I don't think so. I think there were more varietals at the time. I think Saint Sault definitely from the beginning. I think Cabernet came in at one point because he was friends with Ronald Barton from Chateau Les Villebarton, who's actually an Englishman, but who owned the uh Irishman, I think, who owned the winery in in France and who was posted in the region at one point. So that bring brought in the Cabernet-Sauvignon component, but otherwise all the other varietals were mainly from Rome. And I think we had others. I I think I remember my father saying once that we had Petit Verdot, and we always had maybe one or two rows of things that we were testing, seeing how they would how well they would do, how badly they would do in in our land and with our heat and terroir.
SPEAKER_02When did and I might make an error here in pronunciation, Marwa? Marwa, yes. Of Ovei? Obeide. Obeide. When did those come into the picture? And those are just fun to even know how to say them table sized.
SPEAKER_01No, yeah, I mean they're difficult to pronounce, and this is why we don't necessarily mention them everywhere on our labels, because they're probably too esoteric. So we probably well, I mean we prefer people to focus on chatter miser white, because these are white varietals. So Obede and Meroir are these two local white varietals that I mentioned that are not phylloxera resistant, but that survived phylloxera because they were planted in more remote areas. They were used initially mostly to eat, as grapes to eat, but also to produce arrak. Arak, which is the national spirit in Lebanon, made out of grape juice fermented into wine, fermented and distilled into alcohol. So when my grandfather started, they were there. And so he said, okay, let's use those to produce white wines. On the red side, there were none of the reds that would be good for Vitis vinifera in terms of uh producing white wines. Wines. So that's why he planted or asked farmers to plant Rome varietals mainly.
SPEAKER_02And those are the slow horses in terms of ripening, if I heard correctly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, they are what I call adapted to the terroir. So they ripen, as you say, very, very slowly. We have an entry-level white wine called Muserjeune White, obey, sorry, Vermentino, Viognier, Chardonnay, harvested very early, around August, early August. Very quickly, the sugar levels go through the roof. If you don't harvest, you basically end up with alcohol levels that are above 15 very easily. That's because the terroir is very hot. Then we harvest the reds for another month and a half, and then we harvest Aubin Berois, early October. Now, alcohol level at that point, you would expect it to be much, much higher. Actually, it is not. It's only 12 degrees alcohol, but very concentrated, intense aromatics on these wines. They create wines that can age like for decades, decades. You know, we were opening at the last winefair in Germany, we're opening for three days. We had three older whites that we showed: 1970, 1960, and 1954. And so we're talking more than 70 years old wines. And they just, you know, they last. They're just outstanding. Why? I don't know, to be honest. I mean, it's a combination of it's like life. It's a combination of thousands of different things. Destiny, inheritance from the land. But I guess the question is why do they ripen so late? And I think if they are local, the only way probably to resist to the environment was that they would have to ripen late. Because if they ripen too early, the fruit would fall to the floor too early. Let's say it falls to the floor in August. It's still too hot in Lebanon, they'd have no chance of survival. As in the grains could not be picked maybe by birds and go somewhere else just because it was just all burned too quickly. Whereas if they ripened in October, then it was already past the very hot part of the season. And therefore, maybe there was an opportunity for that vine to survive and then to expand. So you're talking about Darwin in a way, yeah, in terms of the survival of the fittest. And this is probably why these varietals survived, is because they have this very late ripening process. And even if it's ripened, it doesn't reach a lot of alcohol. It's this is the nature of the beast, as I say.
SPEAKER_02The idea to select grapes that are ostensibly now from the same region, Chardonnay, Viognier, and Vermentino. How did you all land there?
SPEAKER_01There. It's a good question. So that decision was taken before I joined my family in terms of working in it. Chardonnay made sense. Well, maybe let me take a step back. Before Musard jeune white, which is Viagnet Vermentino Chardonnay, we used to have what we call the Cuvé Musard, which was our entry-level white. And that was produced with Obedet. The Chateau was produced with Merois, Chateau as in our top label, but with Meroir and Obedet, and Obedet was there only for the Cuvée. But when you're trying to reach new markets that don't know about Lebanon and that are discovering your wines, and you need an entry-level wine where people can pronounce the varietals. And it's relatively simple. I mean, this is how I explained it today. I don't know if that was the driver of the decision at the time. The idea was to then, and also the wines of Obeide, when they're young, tend to be very austere. And so we thought, okay, let's go with varietals that are probably closer to home to our new markets that we'll be discovering. In the end, the blend makes sense because Chardonnay gives you this butteriness that allows to have enough weight on the palate for food. And Viognier and Vermontino give you a lot of the aromatics. And so you can end up with a wine that you can have with food or on its own, really depending on how you want to pair it. And we've tested with other varietals as well into the blend, but in the end, this is these are the three that we are really focusing on.
SPEAKER_02I'm gonna pull on a different thread now, Mark. Your father takes over around the late 50s, 1959, early 60s. It's really not until late 79 that you have sort of a quote unquote break, per se, in with the gatekeeper of the world in terms of distribution. What did business look like before people found out?
SPEAKER_01Like what was your father doing to spread the gospel? Well, if you think of 60s and early 70s in Lebanon, that was the time of you know the plenty in Lebanon. People were going out, Lebanon was the price of the Middle East, it was the place to be in terms of the jet setting, going out, enjoying life. I think by 1975, we were selling still 99% of our wines in Lebanon. And we had no need to go anywhere else. The war started within a couple of years, we had almost no market locally, because you know, when you're at war and you're such a small country, that really affected our sales. And so in a in a way, people say, ah, war must have been really difficult. Yes, it was very difficult. But this is where resilience and adaptability kicks in. And I think that's probably part of what we as ex-Phoenicians or like ancestors, you know, descendants of the Phoenicians, we just adapt. And so it forced us to go outside of the country and start looking at different markets. So, in a way, should the war have not happened, we might have still been selling our wines mostly in Lebanon. I mean, eventually we probably would have done it somewhere else. But what it did was it it forced us from one day to the other to say, okay, we need to sell our wines. Where do we go? And from 75 to 91, which is the length of the civil war in Lebanon, we were so it's a very long period, we're talking 16, 17 years. We went from selling 99% in Lebanon to selling 99% outside of Lebanon. Yeah, and then eventually now we were at 15% sold in Lebanon. But in a way, it forced us to go outside. And we were lucky that in 1979 we were showing our wines at the Bristol Wine Fair. That's when Michael Broadbunt eventually tasted the wines. He was the wine critic for Decanter Magazine. He was also the buyer, or the not the buyer, I guess, the main person in charge of the wine program at Christie's at the auction house. And so he wrote about our wines. And you know, the discovery of the fair for him was Chateau Mizard. And this is how things started to develop in the UK. We opened a company in the UK, started selling a bit more directly ourselves, which we thought was better than giving our wines to a distributor, because we could at least we could explain them if we had our own team doing it. And that's when in 1984, the Cantor magazine, that's the UK magazine for wines, started uh giving an award for the they used to call it the Man of the Year award. Now it's called the Personality of the Year for obvious reasons, because there's been women and everything. And so uh yeah, the first person to get that award was Serge. So my father.
SPEAKER_02Not only that's an amazing feat, I mean, the world of wine sometimes has been accused for being kind of ossified in like old-world classic wines, and to break into that barrier, you know, obviously in America, the Paris judgment of 1976 was pivotal, but to break into that old world market, especially from a place like Lebanon, which most people may not, I mean, even to this day, associate with winemaking, I think that's amazing. I mean, that's a reflection of what was in the bottle, obviously. And partially a little bit of grace, luck, and your dad's energy and who he was and charisma, yes, and and passion.
SPEAKER_01He yes, absolutely. I mean, it's a mix of different things that happen at the same time. And I think this is where you again, if I come back to this point of resilience and of just this, we're used to it in Lebanon. Lebanon is the phoenix. It always rises again from its ashes. And I think we're doing that whole process again now in 2025 after what's happened in the last uh year and a half. And you see a hurdle, you have to figure out how to manage that hurdle, how to cross it. And it creates opportunities on the other side. You just need the right people, the right passion, and the right stubbornness. We talked about the Chateau Miser white. For many, many years, people would not understand Chateau Miser white at all. In a sense where I remember my father having other, you know, winemakers telling him, or mentioning without necessarily telling him directly, that you know, Obed and Mawah are not wines, are not grapes that should be used for wines. I mean, the the wines are just not what a white wine should be. And he insisted, insisted, insisted, and continued producing them, continued producing them. And eventually, like our non-interventionist philosophy came back to the forefront. Today it's the same with the whites. I mean, a lot of winemakers in the last 20 years have used Chateau Miser white as a bit of a reference in terms of people call it oxidative in style, but I don't think it's oxidative. It's just the nature of the grapes. But you realize that these wines have such an ability to develop over time and they need time.
SPEAKER_02When they say oxidative, is it because it has a sort of nutty cherry-esque quality to it? Issue of color. What are they confabulating with just a completely different expression of these grapes in that part of the world versus it's oxidative?
SPEAKER_01Elo, you're asking exactly the right question. Many people tell me oh it's oxidative, and I tell them it's not. And there's a very reason, simple reason for this. If you take a Sauvignon Blanc, you open it, it's fresh, it's grapes. And we don't have that in Lebanon, at least not at Musea. You wait two hours, you start to see the oxidation comes in. It doesn't keep that fruit, you know, eventually the evolution really kicks in. At Musear, you open a bottle, that same type of oxidation that you identified, maybe in the Sauvignon Blanc after two hours or three hours, is there from the beginning. And you wait two or three hours with Chateau Miser white, and it doesn't get more, it doesn't increase. On the contrary, you start to have fruit, you have flowers, you have dried uh things that dried fruits that that start to kick in. So instead of oxidation going up, as you would expect it from another white wine, you almost feel like it's coming down because the rest is coming up. So this is why I don't call it oxidation, because it doesn't behave in the same pattern. It's just that the flavor profile, when it's just open, seemed like it has this evolution, but give it one hour, two hours, one day, one week, one month. I opened even bottles with my I mean, uh I remember having a tasting, not a tasting, I was arriving in Beirut, and my father gives me a I was with my brother and my father at the uh office in Beirut, and he gives me a glass, he says, What is this? White wine, so I know it, and I know it's bizarre because he didn't drink anything else. And wait, wait, was he really? I mean, he drank his own Kool-Aid, he loved drinking his wine. Yes, yes. And he loved because they always were different, they were always changing. So he wanted really to experience them to the full because every bottle is different, every vintage is different, every vintage evolves over 30, 40, 50 years, and we have a lot of wine because we keep this whole library. So obviously there was always an opportunity to learn from the wines. Anyway, so he gives me this white wine to taste, and I go through the motions, and I'm thinking, okay, this is 89 white. Yeah, 89 white, beautiful vintage, very complex, a lot of layers of, you know, again, walnuts, honeydew, apricot, dried fruits, I mean, layers. And he tells me, no, it's not 89 white, it's O4 white. And that was probably in 2014, so 10 years old wine. And I tell him, that's not O4. O4 is extremely elegant, very subtle, more on flowers. He says, no, no, this is O4. But I opened it a while ago. So I said, okay, we were in September. He had opened it in January. And not using a coravan, not using a fridge, not pumping air out of the bottle, just closing the bottle with a cork, leaving it at the office in Beirut, exposed to extreme, you know, variations in temperature. And so, yeah, by then you could call it that they were starting to get oxidation, but we're talking obviously uh nine months into uh having opened the bottle. But the wines showed the same evolution, at least this is why I identify, as uh 15 more years in a bottle. And yeah, beautiful.
SPEAKER_02And maybe there's no answer to this, Mark, but considering that both these grape varietals tend to hang for a long time, it's fair to say phenolically they're a little more robust. And also the pH has to be quite low with these grapes for them to sustain that vibrancy and that life, or are we just now cogitating over stuff that we can't answer?
SPEAKER_01Look, there's so many things that we sh think should make sense in terms of the what's behind the chemistry, but then all of a sudden you find out that it's the exact opposite and it still works. Yeah. And that's the beauty about wine. Now, uh do I know the exact pH of every single vintage of the the white scene? I don't. What I know is the pattern of how they behave over time. And that pattern is just this ability to withstand time and uh air over time. And uh that's what makes them an ode to life in a way. That I have this ability to age so long.
SPEAKER_02But I can't see a bit of mystery behind these wines.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you can call it mystery. Somebody called it art. I call it life in a sense that it's a real testimony to life. That's the the most beautiful way of describing it, I think.
SPEAKER_02Let's talk about then more life. Yeah. We briefly talked about the wine growing. In the winemaking, was the decision to at least go through primary fermentation in concrete always the case?
SPEAKER_01So uh historically, yes. In the Tsar Palace that I was mentioning when my grandfather started, it was cement. It was concrete vats that were built at the bottom of the cellars of that palace. When we started to grow in terms of production, my grandfather bought a house next to the Tsar Palace, and it's over that house that he built the new winery and around it. And then gradually we built new buildings around it as we were expanding uh production. And so uh, yes, it was always concrete from the beginning, and when we built it, we're talking 50s, the new winery, that was mostly concrete. We also experimented with stainless. We use stainless for our jeune white and jeune rosé wines because it's easier to cool them down, which is part of the process of how you you make your white wines, at least those that don't go through wood for like for us. But we don't use reds. We tried using the stainless steel for reds, but we found that because we bottled so late, within after a year, year and a half, and sometimes three years, stainless steel didn't give the wines enough complexity. Cement seems to give more complexity to our wines. And I think lately many of the Bordeaux wineries have reopened. I think Cheval Blanc has rebuilt its own winery and it's all in cement. No.
SPEAKER_02In terms of Ella Vash, they undergo primary, you know, you finish fermentation in concrete, eventually you do barrel down. They do go into barrel. And the reason why I asked that question is in terms of the influence of new oak, in my experience, it's barely discernible with the wines that I've had. At Mizarre. Yes. So you use a little bit of new wood or is it all neutral?
SPEAKER_01So we use small barracks, so 300 bottle uh barracks, the least toasted possible. So that again, because our whole approach is non-interventionist, meaning I don't want to influence in any way the juice with I don't want vanilla and there, I don't want anything that's gonna impact its juice. And it's the same reason why we only use 10% new wood every year, on average, for the red. So 10% is really not much. And the reason we use wood is not for the flavor, it's really for the vaccination, the inoculation, the fact that the wines get accustomed to a little bit of air. And so that when they end up in the bottle, at the end of year three, in the case of the Chateau Red or top label, they have understood what oxygen is. And when they end up in the bottle, they are exposed to the most oxygen ever compared to their whole previous life. In VATs, and maybe in wood there's a little bit of air, in vats there's almost none. In a bottle, there's this little space between the cork and the wine. And so that is uh oxygen. And so if they've gone through a process of learning how to deal with oxygen before, including that one period of time in wood, they probably deal better. And so it's it's all about yes, this vaccination process that happens in the internet.
SPEAKER_02And so the approach obviously is a great deal of restraint and as you say, the vaccination to get a little more microoxygen into the life of the wine in barrel. Is there a specific approach pertaining to what barrels you use? Is it all is it French or so?
SPEAKER_01We use one so since my grandfather started, we use one barrel maker. I can't I can't remember the name of what how do you call that, but one from France, from another.
SPEAKER_02A coupric? From a couprise from France?
SPEAKER_01Yes, yes, from France, called uh dentos, uh, you know, and we've been using them since ever, probably 80 years, 90 years, whatever. And we don't change. Not because we're not wanting to experiment, but because when you think a winery and Mizarre, and if you taste many vintages, they're all different. They all age differently, but they all age well, but there is a signature, an identity that remains. Even though you would taste them all, if you taste five consecutive vintages and you're blind, you might not even think that they are from the same winery. But there is still an identity that that stays. And part of that identity may be the wood that we use. And so we could experiment with others, but honestly, we're very happy with what it does. And we don't want to tweak even more. Now, if we create a new wine that goes through wood, we could eventually test something else, but we've been very happy with what we've done and and and what we've used.
SPEAKER_02When I answered the question about Chateau Moussard being aspirational, I also right away knew that it was painfully unreplicable. You cannot replicate what Chateau Moussard is, from the vineyard to the trajectory of the grapes to the winemaking decisions. The reason why I mentioned that, and now I want to speak about Lebanon a little more, there was when Gabriel Garcia Marquez was being interviewed, he was talking about what his body felt when he would return to Colombia, that it was undeniable, that your body just vibrated differently, maybe because it knew that that's where it came from when it was little. And I heard you say once that to even understand Chateau Moussar a little more, you have got to go to Lebanon. Because although it's been through its ups and downs, there is a through line of this joy de vivir when you when you go to Lebanon, and it's a sort of a collective understanding that when you go there, something happens that is terribly enjoyable and arresting.
SPEAKER_01Can you please speak to that? So my experience with Lebanon is love and hate. And I think a lot of people from my generation and the following generations have had that. Well, I grew up, we had to leave Lebanon because of the war. We stayed a few years, and then we were going back for holidays there. But I felt that this attachment to the land was came at a price of instability, of insecurity, of everything. It's only when I started getting a little bit older than you start to realize that roots are important. It's not that they're important because they have to be important, it's just they're important because you feel them. It's like part, as you say, part of your DNA. And then so I would go back to Lebanon when I was in my 20s and would say, okay, have fun, but very happy to leave. And then in my 40s, I would come back, and for some reason there was this eagerness to live that I felt. When you come to Lebanon and you are there, you want to live to the max a thousand percent every day. And you don't postpone things. I lived in France, I lived in Italy, uh, sorry, in uh Dubai, I lived in England, I lived in Germany. And in those places, I would have my life, go to work, live, but then feel that, okay, if I couldn't do something today, I would just do it tomorrow. Because that's the way, at least I felt it. But when I go to Lebanon, you feel that everything has to, if you have to do something, you have to do it now. And this eagerness to live is, I don't know if it's linked to all the conflict and the strife that we had, and the fact that you you're not sure what's going to happen the next day, and therefore you want to enjoy life to the max because of the uncertainty, or it's just because also it's the land and it just makes you want to experience all of it at the same time and now in the present. And that is something that I feel now, despite all the love and hate that I had earlier in my past. But I know that when some foreigners who have nothing to do with Lebanon come to Lebanon and they enjoy the weather, the people, the food, the hospitality, the way we just live, and they just fall in love with Lebanon. Now, whether they want to stay there and live their whole life is a different matter. But once they are there, they really understand what it is to live with the capital L.
SPEAKER_02I'm gonna ask you uh an ignorant question. How many languages are spoken in Lebanon? So official language is Arabic.
SPEAKER_01But people speak also English and French, depending on you know where which school they went to, which area they they grew up in. And most of the cases three languages.
SPEAKER_02At least for me, it goes without saying that when I think of wine and I think of Lebanon, there's only one name, which is Chateau Moussar. As of now, I believe there's about 60 producers in the Becca. Approximately. So one thing that we've never or I've never heard in any interviews is the food culture in Lebanon. And Chateau Moussar, like what's the food in Lebanon like?
SPEAKER_01So Lebanese food is actually becoming more and more mainstream now in terms of being accessible to a lot of people around the world. Because a lot of, I mean, we don't export many things out of Lebanon. We export wine, food, a bit of designers, like the big designers, and people, as in talent. And okay, some fruits and vegetables locally. But that's it. And so food, and for a long time, actually, even Musa was part of brand Lebanon in terms of how do you identify what do you know about Lebanon if you're outside of Lebanon and are exposed to that country. And food now is really becoming one of the main drivers as well. So restaurants popping up everywhere. Homus, you know, is the staple of food in Lebanon. There's so many different dishes when you're at a table in Lebanon, you're overwhelmed by, I don't know, 20, 30, depends how big your table is and how big your group is, but 20, 30 small dishes that you dip in, mostly veg vegetables. And in Lebanon, you never finish everything that's on the table. Why? I mean, people, you know. Wait, culturally speaking, you never or is because there's so much food? Because there's a lot of food and because it's a question of hospitality. There's always needs to be extra food in case somebody is still hungry. So, you know, when you're coming from the West and you look at this, you think, oh, this is a waste. But it's part of how we receive people at Lebanon. It's part of the hospitality. And so when you go to a restaurant, yeah, you will have that. I tend to be a bit, you know, more restrictive because I don't want to eat too much. The problem is you end up by eating too much when there's a lot of food on the table. But that's the spirit. And that is the reflection of the hospitality and the spirit of the Lebanese people.
SPEAKER_02Well, I think it goes without saying, Mark, that having grown up as a young person in New York City from Colombia, I mean, I'm half Serbian, half Colombian, in the 80s and 90s, where Colombia was not necessarily known for anything good. I've always felt like a low-level pressure to make sure that if somebody knew I was from Colombia that I was showcasing my country in a positive light. I think that Chateau Moussar, you have not only trailblazers in terms of putting, you know, wines from there on the map, but through the work of the family, and you know, I've just met you directly, but the stories continue to be shared pertaining to what it meant to be in the presence of your family and the generosity of spirit and the magic that are these wines, which again, I did name it one of my most iconic wines because it almost defies definition, because it's inedito. There's like, there's no other wine that could be like that wine. And I can't thank you enough for sitting down with me. I don't know if I forgot to ask you something else, but if there's anything else you'd like to share with us that you think we should know, at least for the hearing now, I know there's some fun stuff coming up, new projects. Maybe if I hear correctly, you have some coastal vineyards in the works.
SPEAKER_01Most of our vineyards are in the Bekavali at a thousand meters. But we also found one piece of land above Byblos, which is on the coastline. Byblos is a very old city, the second longest continuously inhabited city in the world, 10,000 years of uh of history, it's a port, used by the Phoenicians. And above that, we found a piece of land called the Way of the Vine. The Way of the Vine? The Way of the Vine that was never planted with vines in terms of recent history, yeah, obviously. And when we we found it, we looked at a piece of land that looks beautiful, and then we when we started inquiring about it, it turned out that was the name. But it was all bushes, and so we actually planted all of that. Mostly Maroih, local white grapes, and also Sansel. So these two uh these are the two varietals in that plot of land. But it's lower, it's 400 meters of altitude, it's facing towards the sea, so it's a very different environment and climate to the Bika Valley, which is much higher and less exposed to humidity. But we were surprised within three years, we were starting to get quite a bit of juice out of those vines. And yes, a lot of rocks, a lot of limestone, very little clay, but a view of the sea. So nice.
SPEAKER_02Are you continuing your father's legacy, his conversation in the bottle? And are you moving forward perhaps having your own opinion as well with your brother? Undoubtedly, yes.
SPEAKER_01There's no way we can replicate. And you mentioned earlier that you know it's very distinctive, it's very unique at Mizarre. Even if we were to take our winery and build a new winery a hundred meters away, the wines would be different. Because the ambient yeasts, wine is a a thousand or million different things that happen, and then eventually you end up with what you have as wine. So are we making the same decisions that would have been taken by my grandfather or my father? Of course not. Are we following the same methodology, footsteps? Yes, the same approach, the same non-intervention. But in the end, it's all about creating or continuing the identity of Mizarre. And when my brother, who's in charge of all the wine, we have our winemaker as well, and myself, we sit down to do the blend of the Chateau Red, for example, every year. We taste many varietals because we keep every varietal separate, every plot of land separate, and it's only after two years that we blend them. We taste, I mean, there's thousands of combinations possible, huh? Because you take one, two percent, three percent out of a vat, or you add them, and that changes a bit. So we do, let's say, five or six different plans that we think are likely to work. I taste differently from my brother, who tastes differently from my winemaker, and differently as in in terms of what we like and what we don't like, because each of us has this personality. But we usually agree on what is the identity of miser, which is not necessarily the wine that my brother or Tarek or myself would prefer. It's really what we think is the identity of misery. And so I would say I like this one, but I will vote for this one as a blend for miser. And same for Gaston, etc. And this is where it's a challenge, but we usually tend to agree on what is the identity of miserable. And it's very difficult to describe because when you're preparing wine or to blend, you're blending not for now, you're blending for five years, ten years, twenty years, thirty, forty years from now, at least at Miser. It's not that our wines are going to be sold in two years. They're gonna be sold after when we blend the chateau at year two, it's gonna be sold five years later and it's gonna age another, you know, three, four, five decades. So it's trying to envisage where these wines will go. It's a gamble. Um, every single decision is a gamble. And yes, I mean, we've been managing to obviously continue. My brother was with my father for 20 years before he passed away. So a lot of that information has gone down through the generation. Now the challenge is the next one, the next generation. And so we're we're working on that. Hopefully, one of the three children of my brother has three three children, my cousin has two, I have one. We'll see who wants to join and and continue that path.
SPEAKER_02Well, I've always found that wine in general has this egalitarian quality that levels the playing field and it transcends differences, where you're from or politics. It blocks out all that noise, Mark. And at least for me and a lot of people that I've offered your wine to at the restaurant, I know that we have been the beneficiaries of that little slice of this thing that happens in the other side of the world. And then you have somebody talking about it in the other side of the world, and you allow people to, for a little while, stop and enjoy life. So thank you for your work and thank you to your family.
SPEAKER_01Thank you very much, Pavle. It was really nice talking and sharing a little bit of what we do at Mizarre and how we how we view things. Ashante. Ashante.
SPEAKER_02And that brings us to the end of the show. But before we say ciao ciao, I wanted to let you know that if there are any questions about winemaking you'd like me to tackle on the pod, don't hesitate to email me at ps atpablomilic.com. That's P S S T at Pablomilic.com. Also, if you like the content and you know someone who would get value from it, please share it. And lastly, if you have been enjoying the show, head on over to wherever you listen, leave us a review, and subscribe. Until next time, this is your host, Pablo Millik.